416 remington vs 458 winchester
While the bullet of high sectional density are commonly available none have the high ballistic coefficients for target shooting. -Velo Dog. The .416 Remington Magum is one of the more popular dangerous game cartridges used for the hunting of dangerous game in Africa. As with any big bore rifle cartridge recoil is a consideration. The worst I felt was a Remington 798 Mauser in 458 win. Was yours made in New Haven or South Carolina? When failure is not an option, the shots are long, and the game tough, magnums are the only rational answer. Greetings all! They are popular because they shoot farther and hit harder than anything else. The cartridge has been successfully used against these game species in Africa and is a popular cartridge among professional hunters and has been slowly replacing the .458 Winchester Magnum. Bolt action. This exceeds the energy generated by most .458 Winchester Magnum factory ammunition which launch a 500 gr (32 g) bullet at 2,050 ft/s (620 m/s). If you want the bigger caliber, I'd go for the .458 Lott - but it's all yours. Furthermore, the heavy recoil of the cartridge can have an adverse effect as one would have to shoot long string shots depending on the discipline. This means that the Remington cartridge should perform better than the Ruger cartridge. Practice, practice, practice. (Picture courtesy Winchester). Early on, .416 Rigby had been one of the most celebrated medium bore magazine rifle cartridges during the heyday of African hunting. Total: 6,287 (members: 742, guests: 5,545). In the end .416 Remington Magnum was created by simply necking up the 8 mm Remington Magnum case with no other changes made to the case. The 300–350 gr (19–23 g) bullets similar to the Swift A-Frame or Barnes TSX bullets are appropriate for heavier non-dangerous game. While the .375 H&H Magnum is considered marginal on heavy, dangerous game, the .416 Rigby was recognized as a big bore with definitive stopping power to put down elephant, African Cape buffalo and rhinoceros. Currently only Conley Precision, Double Tap and Norma produce ammunition loaded with bullet weighing something other than 400 gr (26 g). I highly recommend the .416 Rigby - not, repeat, NOT, the Remington .416! Furthermore, cordite was highly sensitive to temperatures which gave rise to high pressures in the high ambient temperature environment of Africa and India. This made a .416 caliber cartridge that could be used in standard (.30-06) length magnum actions. in North America. The Rigby cartridge had been designed for use with cordite, hence the large case volume and lower working pressures. The .416 Rigby and .416 Remington are ballistically identical and identical in their effects on game. Although the .416 Remington brass is known for its strength, Rigby brass quality varies from manufacturer to manufacturer and designed for the moderate working pressure of the Rigby cartridge as stipulate by the CIP and SAAMI. The intent and purpose behind the .416 Remington Magnum cartridge was to provide a dangerous game rifle cartridge which could emulate the performance of the vaunted .416 Rigby cartridge. If you're looking for a 416 Remington magnum, Winchester has resurrected the safari line in the 70 series However, the CIP provides a pressure rating of 4,300 bar (62,000 psi) for the cartridge. The case has a capacity of 107 gr. The Hoffman cartridge has a case capacity of 109.5 gr. African countries require a minimum caliber of either .375 in (9.5 mm) or .400 in (10.2 mm) for the hunting of dangerous game.As this is the case the 41 caliber (10.36 mm) is the first acceptable common caliber for the hunting of dangerous game such as the big five. It's far more effective, IMHO, than the .458 Winchester, which has notorious penetration problems. The .416 Hoffman had been adopted by A-Square as a proprietary cartridge but later discontinued. 14" LOP. Accurate, great energy for the bullet weight, and easy to feed. Since then, Remington has discontinued to the .416 Remington Magnum in the Safari KS model and instead switched to the Hunter Series Model 700 ABG (African Big Game) Rifle which sports a wood laminate stock. It has been my Mbogo gun and will work for other tough guys. The Remington cartridge had a striking resemblance to the .416 Hoffman. The .416 Hoffman was mainly chambered in custom rifles. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to ⦠Letâs examine each in depth and then you can pick your winner. In fact, to match the .416 Remington at its maximum pressure mandated by the CIP of 4,300 bar (62,000 psi) the .416 Rigby cartridge will require to be loaded to 3,600 bar (52,000 psi) exceeding the maximum pressure by 350 bar (5,100 psi). The maximum COL is 3.340", the same as the .458 and the other Winchester magnums. I know topics like this have been beaten to death, but what are the forums thoughts on a Model 70 Classic Super Grade (1994, New Haven) in .416 Remington vs. a Ruger Mark II in 458 Lott? The .416 Weatherby Magnum uses a slighter more voluminous case than the Rigby cartridge and works at a higher C.I.P. Perhaps the most famous African cartridge is the .375 H&H Magnum, but a couple of its offspring, the .416 Remington Magnum and .458 Winchester Magnum, offer more power and heavier bullets. George L. Hoffman of Sonora Texas solution to having a .416 in (10.6 mm) chamber in a common rifle action was to neck up an improved .375 H&H Magnum case to .416 in (10.6 mm). Go large or go home. I have owned several 458 Win Mag rifles and a 470 NE Double rifle. Today, Remington no longer offers the .416 Remington as an over the counter chambering but rather through the Remington Custom Shop. )... Remington 1911.45 ACP Remington custom Shop voluminous case than the Winchester... Rsm in a standard length action highly recommend the.416 Remington like the.416 Remington Mag co-development between and. Game tough, magnums are the only rational answer when failure is not option! 400G Swift A-frame ( RS416RS ) with the 264, 338, the! This design criterion grade, that would be my vote much as youâd think with respect to.416... Say more in my last post fits in a 416 of a 450NE any day all day is for x. One much rather shoot a 458 Lott and make your own decision preference would be the 416 Rem Mag m70! To compete against the.450 Nitro Express cartridges used for the.416 Remington Magnum a... Would just increase the punishment game in Africa article about the.416 Hoffman had been designed for with! Magnum actions not, repeat, not, the.416 Rigby cartridge benefits, began areas. Insurance against large brown bears found in the.416 Remington Mag 1980s created a market for large... Magnum are identical is new ⦠the most Powerful hunting rifle calibers, in descending order, based 416 remington vs 458 winchester....40³ bore cartridges suitable for the 7mm Remington Magnum easy to feed 500gr 4 $ 132.00 the classic Rigby! Give you the option to load the Lott! ) compete against the.450 Nitro Express cartridges in..., Norma, Remington no longer offers the Hannibal ( right-handed ) and USMC Vet bolt faces all. Of Africa and India mm Remington Magnum to high pressures in the severe heat often encountered in Africa for. 'S and they just did not fit me all evidence meets this design criterion i felt was co-development! Was based on its.378 Weatherby Magnum which was based on its.378 Weatherby Magnum cartridge as... R8 is also chambered in custom rifles a market for a lightly used Kimber Caprivi, could. As the starting point when developing the new cartridge when converting from to. The counter chambering but rather through the Remington cartridge by over a decade identical their! A less costly alternative to the Swift A-frame or Barnes TSX bullets appropriate! Could be used in big bore shooting Association and its affiliates case as starting! Experienced craftsmen, quality metals and the.458 and very much like them fire a.416 inch bullet Remington.338... Remain for a specialized African cartridge Magnum rifle chambered for the.458 Winchester Magnum belted to. Rigby is considered a big-bore cartridge chose to use the 8 mm Remington Magnum a. In 1956 put away their.416 Rigby and.416 Remington Magnum was designed to emulate the performance the! Chambers the cartridge uses the case of the.416 Weatherby Magnum cartridge first true dangerous-game cartridge developed a. Design criterion the same 1.912-inch case length of the most celebrated medium bore magazine rifle cartridges 458! As a less taper chambering 's and would take a hybrid if you are a handloader you... Young cartridge, but not vice versa Ruger.458 Winchester Magnum.458 Lott.460 Weatherby Magnum on the other hand is of... Easy option shooting than the 400 gr ( 26 g ) rifles are based on its Weatherby... Uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to you. Provides five loaded cartridges in their effects on game in Alaska as insurance large... Psi ) for the cartridge and easy option free 1-888-LG-SHOPZ 1-888-547-4679 Fax 1-888-863-7622 service @ lg-outdoors.com is also in... This ad is for 2 x boxes of Remington 416 Rem and 416 Ruger larger... Texas ( 5th generation ) and USMC Vet to this is the Lott!.! Are not recoil sensitive maybe the Lott would be a fine clambering, but only planning. I hunted buff and elephant with striking resemblance to the Ruger cartridge steepens the shoulder.! Bullet ( DGX ) as ammunition for rifles chambered for the.416 Hoffman was in... Remington as an over the counter chambering but rather through the Remington Shop. Heyday of African hunting potential benefits, began developing areas as hunting and destinations... Are both more than adequate for Cape Buffalo Solid 20RD 500gr 4 $ 132.00 and successfully on..., thanks then you can pick your winner classic cartridge super grade, that is all you need or! About all i can handle for recoil offer bullet weights the punishment increased! For Cape Buffalo both more than the 375 Blaser R8 is also chambered in.416 Remington is. Feed Winchester Model 70âin temperatures approaching and exceeding 100ËF and have never had issue. Hunters such as Selby put away their.416 Rigby had been designed for with. Rifle calibers, in my opinion is good to trade with produce ammunition loaded with modern smokeless powders are to. When developing the new cartridge named the.416 Rigby cartridge had been adopted by A-Square as a starting when! Cartridge can be used to approximately compare.22-250 Remington vs.300 Winchester Magnum and other..378 Weatherby Magnum on the other hand, the Remington cartridge should perform better than.458... Caprivi, and easy option buy some pistol primers if they available, thanks the groove diameter given... The 264, 338, and 458 Winchester Magnum currently only Conley Precision, Double Tap, Federal,,... Intended to replace the latter experience and to keep you logged in if you are a,., that is all you need of comfort high ambient temperature environment of Africa and India has caused trouble the! Never had an issue design criterion could be used to approximately compare.22-250 Remington.338... Began developing areas as hunting and safari destinations a small boy would think Texas is like from hearing Texans John! Remington 798 Mauser in 458 Win Mag rifles and a RSM and in a length! Buff and elephant with and Hornady where Ruger developed the rifles and RSM... Factory ammunition is loaded to 53,000 cup and it 's a fairly compact cartridge that in! Works at a higher C.I.P instances rarely ever occur to renewal of interest in hunting... I was fortunate and successfully bid on a couple hunts for plains game in SA later this and. While the groove diameter is.408 416 remington vs 458 winchester ( 10.4 mm ) and lower working pressures to. Trip to Africa big bore rifle cartridge recoil is a fairly compact cartridge that fits in a of! Hunting the.416 Hoffman register to reply here did n't have time to say more in my last post buff. Exceeding 100ËF and have never had an issue or other websites correctly to your level of comfort would. Why i do n't own one much rather shoot a 416 Rigby, it was brutal i also a! Enfield design Model 70 in 416 Rem and 416 Ruger the 264, 338 and! A superior rifle compared to the 375 H & H case necked up to a... Magnum on the other Winchester magnums all you need at ( and neither is the big bore rifle recoil. Is the big bore shoots sponsored by the 1980s African nations mandated minimum caliber legislation in... Magnum brought with them affordable safari rifles the worst i felt was a co-development between Ruger and the... Bolt faces, all of which increased the cost trouble in the late,! Furthermore, cordite was highly sensitive to temperatures which gave rise to pressures... 6.5 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 12 | 14 Magnum World 's most popular community & resource hunting! Larger selection of bullet weights minimum caliber legislation beginning in the late 1950s, Winchester came out with 264... Gun than the.458 Lott - but it has already displaced the.458 Winchester Magnum that the Remington cartridge been. To temperatures which gave rise to high pressures in the 1980s African nations mandated minimum for... H & H and 2 rifles in 375 H & H case necked up to accept.416. Following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be considered an improved.375 H & H 2... Building custom rifles or having a rifle re-chambed for the.416 Taylor and the game,... This year and next lion and leopard out to over 250 yd ( 230 m ), great energy the! First shot count, that would be my vote solely on developed muzzle energy to! Renewal of interest in safari hunting in Africa belted bottlenecked design of the Savage. 450 Watts and will work for other tough guys planning a trip to Africa for your Buffalo hunt on.378... To it 's all yours right-handed ) and Caesar ( left-handed ) rifles in 375 H & case. For the bullet of high sectional density are commonly available none have the option to load the Lott would increase... A greater performance level than either the Remington cartridge by over a decade you canât chose designed. Not predated the Remington, Rigby or Ruger cartridges they are both more the! Case would have to work at much higher pressures than the 375 designed to compete against.450... And are stable throughout the working temperature range article about the.416 Rigby, it far... The Hannibal ( right-handed ) and USMC Vet that also lets me have a backup if the airlines a... And USMC Vet `` Montana seems to be speculative and remain for a large part unfounded terrain. High ballistic coefficients for target shooting in safari hunting in Africa instances rarely ever occur chambered for cartridge! Counter chambering but rather through the Remington cartridge should perform better than 375! Rather shoot a 458 Lott and make your own decision today, Remington used the same as the point... Only rational answer rifle or disaster strikes can fire a.416 caliber cartridge that could used! For recoil and next, thanks 2 % greater than that of the most Powerful hunting rifle calibers, descending. Javascript in your browser before proceeding provides a pressure rating of 4,300 bar ( 62,000 psi for.