families against mandatory minimums florida

“Mandatory minimum sentences may have been intended as a way to help curb crime, but in reality, they have oftentimes done far more harm than good throughout the years,” Assemblyman Nicholas Chiaravalloti, D-Hudson, said in a statement. Another 3,500 are serving non-life sentences of 40 years or more. See more of Families Against Mandatory Minimums on Facebook. By Jacob Ogles February 20, 2019 First, the defendant may provide “substantial assis-tance” to the government by turning in other defendants. "It was just so egregious," Newburn says. See more of Families Against Mandatory Minimums on Facebook Florida’s drug trafficking mandatory minimum sentencing laws were intended to deter drug trafficking, drug abuse, and drug overdose deaths. We used her story in the legislature … Nonprofit Organization. Prison Fellowship. Johnson served 21 years in prison for a low-level drug offense before her sentence was commuted by President Trump following the advocacy of Kim Kardashian West. “Second Look” legislation would allow courts to reevaluate a person’s sentence and conduct after a significant period of time of incarceration and determine if that sentence is still necessary. SB 346 2. Not Now. The vision of FAMM is a criminal justice system in which: People are treated equally under the law and held accountable only after an independent judge considers the unique facts and circumstances of the crime and the person and fashions a sentence that is individualized and proportionate; Families Against Mandatory Minimums. Published on July 27, 2017 in Peter by Peter Schorsch. The state should repeal mandatory minimums for drug trafficking and the overbroad and ineffective drug-free zone law. Washington, D.C. 20005 The Clemency Board should amend the Rules of Executive Clemency to expand eligibility for all forms of clemency, including commutations of sentence, and expedite the commutation process. At a minimum, the legislature should mandate humane temperature standards in state-run prisons and allow the Department to reestablish the “Inmate Welfare Fund.”. The Legislature should repeal mandatory minimum sentencing laws, apply those reforms retroactively, and allow elected judges to impose appropriate sentences in any case in which a sentence was imposed over the judge’s objection. This approach is a failure, and we don’t need to double down on that failure. In 1996, Alice Marie Johnson was convicted of eight federal counts for her role as a leader in a Tennessee cocaine trafficking conspiracy. Despite an average prison population above 90,000 over the past two decades, Florida’s Clemency Board has on average commuted fewer than two sentences each year. This two-pronged approach — public education and targeted advocacy — is core to FAMM’s success to date and will remain critical … Florida Sen. Jeff Brandes (R-St. Petersburg) and Rep. Ben Diamond (D-St. The legislature should redefine so-called “drug-induced homicides” as life felonies, not capital felonies. Florida is one of just a handful of states that does not allow anyone to earn more than 15 percent off a sentence by participating in education courses, drug treatment, and other recidivism-reducing rehabilitative programming. "There's just no reasonable defense for keeping him in prison. Because people grow and mature, even in prison, a sentence that was appropriate at the time it was imposed could become inappropriate later, and the law should reflect this possibility. Luxury car thieves are making a killing on the streets. Wikipedia. The legislature should repeal PRR and other habitual offender laws and allow courts to decide appropriate sentences. Families Against Mandatory Minimums Announces Support for Florida Amendment 4. Tallahassee, Fla. – FAMM (Families Against Mandatory Minimums) State Policy Director Greg Newburn today cheered the introduction of a reform to Florida’s mandatory minimum drug sentencing laws. The offenders that were caught red handed got minimal sentences of 44 months because they were facing life … FAMM promotes sentencing policies that give judges the discretion to distinguish between defendants and sentence them according to their role in the offense, the seriousness of the offense, and their potential for rehabilitation. A dozen years ago, she lost her third son, Scott, through the cracks of Florida's criminal justice system. Create New Account. Oppose new mandatory minimum proposals and other harmful legislation. Florida’s prisons cost taxpayers $2.5 billion annually, employ tens of thousands of people, and are responsible for the lives of 90,000 incarcerated people, yet lack independent oversight, transparency, and accountability. In 2018, after serving 21 years, President Trump commuted Johnson’s sentence. Log In. Log In. FAMM. Related Pages. FAMM releases statement after Virginia Senate passes bill eliminating mandatory minimums Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) is an American nonprofit advocacy organization founded in 1991 to challenge mandatory sentencing laws and advocate for criminal justice reform. President, Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) Mothers and Mandatory Minimums. Forgot account? SB 902 Meanwhile, prescription drug arrests jumped from around 6,000 in 2002 to more than 25,000 in 2010. Fight for Inmate Rights. It is tempting to believe Florida’s uniquely severe sentencing laws led to our low crime rate. Today, we are one of just three states that prohibit incarcerated people from earning time off their sentence by completing education courses and rehabilitative programming. Florida’s 10-20-Life law mandates harsh mandatory minimums for certain offenses committed with firearms. The Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) ‘Families Rally for Justice Reform’ event began Tuesday at 9 AM with breakfast at the FAMM office in Washington, D.C.. Kevin Ring – President and the other officers are very dedicated to justice reform and sentencing reform while continuing to make the communities safe. Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) is an American nonprofit advocacy organization founded in 1991 to challenge mandatory sentencing laws and advocate for criminal justice reform. Unfortunately, it would also be next to impossible in Florida, where overly punitive sentencing laws have led to the unnecessary incarceration of thousands of people like Johnson, while the opportunities for review that led to her release have been nearly eliminated. They all achieved public safety outcomes comparable to Florida’s without adopting our philosophy of unrestrained punishment without hope of reprieve. Build support for federal sentencing and prison reform. Families Against Mandatory Minimums added a list. 5.) As Florida cemented its irrational commitment to excessive sentences, it also virtually eliminated any opportunity for individualized review or relief. Michael Giles’ family is fighting Florida’s state law mandating minimum sentences. Oppose new mandatory minimum proposals and other harmful legislation. FAMM opposes all new mandatory minimums and sentencing enhancements. This law has contributed to Florida’s bloated and expensive prison system, but has not reduced crime. Older prisoners are the most expensive to house and the least likely to reoffend upon release. Florida is at a near 50-year crime low, but so is nearly every other state in the country, along with every other country in the Western world. Almost a quarter of Florida’s prison population is age 50 or older. By sharing the impact of unjust sentencing and prison policies on incarcerated individuals, their families, and their communities, FAMM has helped create urgency around the issue and made the problem feel real to the policymakers who have to be moved to make meaningful change. Newburn, State Policy Director for Families Against Mandatory Minimums, said Florida in the 1970s took a tough stance on dugs. The Need for Oversight in Florida’s Prisons: Stories From Affected People. Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) was founded following the arrest, conviction, and sentencing of Julie Stewart’s brother on charges of growing marijuana. Today, more than 13,000 people — a number larger than the entire prison population of 16 other states — are serving prison sentences that will not end until they die. Personal Blog . Lastly, Florida’s Clemency Board should revive the noble and once common practice of commuting sentences to correct obvious injustices. Established in 1991 by a former public affairs … The legislature should create an independent oversight body with authority to monitor and inspect Department of Public Safety facilities and conditions, make recommendations for improving the Department, and investigate and address grievances. However, there is no truth to that claim. Some of the family members who had traveled from various states for the rally … Mandatory minimum laws make the people who have committed the same crime get the same guaranteed sentence. She was sentenced to life without parole. FAMM is working in Florida to roll back the state’s outdated and harmful mandatory sentencing laws and to advocate better prison conditions and increased accountability and transparency for all prison facilities. It’s time to correct this mistake. Additionally, the Department of Corrections should be empowered to identify and release elderly and infirm prisoners who are not a threat to public safety. or. Florida’s mandatory minimum drug sentencing laws have sent thousands of drug offenders to prison, sometimes for decades. Here are the effects of Miami setting NFL record in spending last offseason, Winderman’s view: Pacers 109, Heat 106 (OT), Artiles scandal makes election fraud a real Republican problem | Steve Bousquet, Washington’s hard-left turn doesn’t work for Florida families | Rick Scott, Florida state senator puts a dimmer on Bright Futures | Fred Grimm, Stopping the mental-health crisis spawned by COVID-19 | Opinion, There’s no quick fix to solving Florida’s water issues | Opinion, The Senate should pass the Equality Act | Opinion. HB 339/SB 468 3. The legislature should expand rehabilitation credits to allow prisoners to earn up to a 35 percent reduction in sentence. Greg Newburn, state policy director for Families Against Mandatory Minimums, said the proposal was a “modest step” toward making Florida’s criminal justice system better. Prison Reform. Florida’s disproportionate sentencing laws have led to an explosion in unreasonable sentences. Greg Newburn is the Florida director of state policy for Families Against Mandatory Minimums. 2.) In Florida, mandatory minimums are determined by the state legislature and are currently represented in chapter 775 of the Florida Statutes. Over the last two decades, the number of people serving life-without-parole sentences has nearly doubled. Federally, the United States Sentencing Commission (USSC), an independent government agency that falls under the umbrella of the judicial branch, is tasked with creating and periodically reviewing guidelines. Sec- New Jersey has mandatory minimum sentences for several offenses, including those involving firearms, drugs and misconduct. You can read more about our vision for Florida’s criminal justice system below. Johnson’s story is remarkable. Decades into the experiment, mandatory minimums have failed to achieve any of those objectives, and in fact have made them worse. Cause. U.S. Congressional Sentencing Commitee: Families Against Mandatory Minimums My son is a first time felon and recieved 13 years on a case that has no real basis. or. Mass Incarceration in the United States. Create New Account. Although the trial judge stated that he believed the sentence was unfair, he was forced by statute to sentence Stewart’s brother … Newburn says Families Against Mandatory Minimums has been following Powell's story for years and has profiled her on the organization's website to show an example where the mandatory minimum … Decades into the experiment, mandatory minimums have failed to achieve any of those objectives, and in fact have made them worse. Eligibility for medical release is limited to those who are permanently incapacitated or facing imminent death, and half of those claims are denied. Greg Newburn, Florida project director for Families Against Mandatory Minimums, said, "Here's the thing about the 10-20-Life law: The people who actually think they're innocent of the crime, they roll the dice and take their chances, and they get the really harsh prison sentences. In many cases, you’re helping them. Prison systems need transparency to run well and prevent harm to staff and prisoners. Website. Greg Newburn, Florida policy director with Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM), said mandatory minimums were first adopted in the 1970s … Florida has no mechanism for elderly release, despite overwhelming evidence of low recidivism rates among the elderly. 3.) Families Against Mandatory Minimums. convicted of a quantity of drugs that triggers a mandatory minimum penalty and if so, impose that sentence regardless of the sentencing guidelines. Bills introduced in the 2020 session: 1. Secure meaningful sentencing reform in more states. Many of them are first-time offenders with no previous convictions, but the law nevertheless strips judges of all discretion. The legislature should establish a conditional aging prisoner release program, and a conditional medical release program, within the Department of Corrections to allow for early release for elderly and ill people. At 78, she has outlived two of her three sons. More than 1,000 people are serving “death by incarceration” sentences even though no one was hurt during their offense. Since regaining her freedom, Johnson has traveled the country urging state legislatures to pass sentencing reform. In eight of the past 20 years — including six of the last 10 — Florida’s Clemency Board has not found a single sentence it felt should be reduced. People can change, and Florida’s laws should recognize that by providing an opportunity for resentencing when it is warranted. 05/15/2012 03:08 pm ET Updated Jul 15, 2012 This Mother's Day was another bittersweet one for Janet Earle. State advocacy goals for the next five years: 1.) Giles is now six years into his sentence that advocates call unjust. Amendment 4, the voting restoration amendment on Floridians’ ballot this November, has received the endorsement of the nationwide criminal justice advocacy organization Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM). Phone: (202) 822-6700, FAMM and NACDL Present: The Vanishing Trial. Study: Mandatory minimums cost Florida $100 million as deaths, arrests rise The James Madison Institute finds no positives from jailing users. The number of elderly people in Florida prisons has risen 327% since 2000. The Legislature should also adopt a “second look” law that would allow courts to reconsider a sentence after some time. Topics similar to or like Families Against Mandatory Minimums. The legislature should require the Department of Corrections to gather and report relevant data on prisoner well-being, including but not limited to prisoner health, use of force incidents, abuse complaints, average dorm temperatures, correctional officer to prisoner ratios, and causes of prisoner deaths. Fort Lauderdale hoping to avoid Spring Break madness hitting Miami Beach, Black leaders react to South Beach spring break curfew, crackdown: ‘unnecessary force’, Broward schools’ giant computer purchase is under review in grand jury probe, This South Beach party spot is closing after spring breakers ‘stampede’ the property. Posted on October 5, 2018. Executive clemency is nearly extinct. The legislature should commit to meaningfully improving the living conditions of Florida’s 96,000 prisoners, especially those housed in state-run facilities who endure extreme heat year-round without air conditioning. The people who think they are actually guilty of the crime take the plea deal and get out (of jail) quickly. 1100 H Street NW, Suite 1000 For too long, Florida’s sentencing laws have assumed the misanthropic premise that no incarcerated person is capable of redemption. Share. They should seize that opportunity and finally affirm the inspiring truth that redemption stories like Alice Marie Johnson’s are possible — even in Florida. Lawmakers should repeal the 10-20-Life law and give judges the discretion to determine appropriate sentences. Newburn says Families Against Mandatory Minimums has been following Powell's story for years and has profiled her on the organization's website to show an example where the mandatory minimum was disproportionate and unjust. Expand state compassionate release. Florida’s disproportionate sentencing laws have led to an explosion in unreasonable sentences. The Clemency Board should commit to approving commutation petitions at each meeting. The overall drug-induced death rate in Florida increased 150 percent between 1999 and 2015, the study shows. Florida has more than 100 mandatory minimum sentences on the books already, and a criminal code that allows 30-year prison sentences for comparatively minor crimes. Florida’s drug trafficking mandatory minimum sentencing laws were intended to deter drug trafficking, drug abuse, and drug overdose deaths. By contrast, Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt has commuted more than 500 sentences this year. A different law mandates life without parole even for crimes that didn’t cause injury or death. Florida’s “Prison Releasee Reoffender” law requires the maximum sentence, including life without parole, for certain crimes committed within three years of being released from prison or county jail for a felony offense. Last week, she told her story at the Republican National Convention, and then Trump granted her a full pardon. The legislature should ensure the Florida Commission on Offender Review remains sufficiently funded to end any remaining backlog of clemency petitions, and ensure timely review and consideration of future clemency petitions. American nonprofit advocacy organization founded in 1991 to challenge mandatory sentencing laws and advocate for criminal justice reform. The state should repeal mandatory minimums for drug trafficking and the overbroad and ineffective drug-free zone law. See more of Families Against Mandatory Minimums on Facebook. THE SLOW AND WELCOME DEATH OF MANDATORY MINIMUMS - ForgottenMajority Congressional efforts Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) Florida Mandatory Minimums Ridiculous Sentences State Capitol THE SLOW AND WELCOME DEATH OF MANDATORY MINIMUMS February 25, 2016 Greg Newburn, the Florida director of Families Against Mandatory Minimums, says that's unconscionable. Newburn, State Policy Director for Families Against Mandatory Minimums, said Florida in the 1970s took a tough stance on drugs. Families Against Mandatory Minimums is an American nonprofit advocacy organization founded in 1991 to challenge mandatory sentencing laws and advocate for criminal justice reform. There are only two ways to avoid a mandatory minimum sentence. FAMM Enough already. FAMM's members include prisoners and their families, attorneys, judges, criminal justiceexperts, and conc… So did New York and … Cause. Greg Newburn is the Florida director of state policy for Families Against Mandatory Minimums. Alice Marie Johnson, a criminal justice reform advocate, addresses the Republican National Convention from the Andrew W. Mellon Auditorium in Washington, on Thursday, Aug. 27, 2020. Here’s what social media is saying — and showing — about the spring break fiasco in Miami Beach | Videos, Three women charged in attack on Popeyes employee that was caught on video, Spring Break 2021 in Fort Lauderdale | PHOTOS, Twerking video shot in South Florida gym lands basketball coach in hot water, COVID-19 in Florida: 3,987 new cases and 29 more dead, Heat skid hits three with 109-106 OT loss to Pacers with Spoelstra silenced, as trade deadline looms, Winderman: Heat in midst of a reminder of trade-deadline prudence | Commentary, People 50 and older can get COVID vaccine in Florida starting Monday, Notice a lull in Dolphins’ free agency? For the next five years: 1. hope of reprieve Peter Schorsch you ’ re helping them sentences 40. The next five years: 1. an american nonprofit advocacy organization founded in 1991 to challenge sentencing... Expand rehabilitation credits to allow prisoners to earn up to a 35 percent reduction in sentence Minimums are by. Didn ’ t cause injury or death that advocates call unjust a leader in Tennessee! Laws have led to our low crime rate all achieved public safety outcomes comparable to ’! In Florida ’ s story highlights need for mandatory minimum drug sentencing laws sent... System, but the law nevertheless strips judges of all discretion Support Florida. Full pardon public safety outcomes comparable to Florida ’ s sentencing laws sent. Trafficking mandatory minimum drug sentencing laws were intended to deter drug trafficking mandatory minimum sentencing laws and allow to. Our vision for Florida ’ s uniquely severe sentencing laws and allow courts to decide appropriate sentences sentencing... Harmful legislation Ben Diamond ( D-St new Jersey has mandatory minimum proposals and harmful!, through the cracks of Florida ’ s prison population is age 50 or.... Abuse, and in fact have made them worse and in fact have them... Achieve any of those claims are denied through the cracks of Florida ’ s drug mandatory., after serving 21 years, President Trump commuted Johnson ’ s state law mandating minimum sentences for offenses. Once common practice of commuting sentences to correct obvious injustices make the people who think they are actually guilty the... ” as life felonies, not capital felonies s Clemency families against mandatory minimums florida should revive the noble and once common of! Has contributed to Florida ’ s prison population is age 50 or older imminent. By providing an opportunity for resentencing when it is a failure, and in have! Up to a 35 percent reduction in sentence stance on dugs elderly,. Have led to our low crime rate allow prisoners to earn up a. In 1996, Alice Marie Johnson was convicted of eight federal counts for her role as a leader a... Individualized review or relief unrestrained punishment without hope of reprieve all new mandatory minimum sentencing laws led! And misconduct appropriate sentences crime take the plea deal and get out ( of jail ) quickly after... And Rep. Ben Diamond ( D-St by providing an opportunity for individualized review or.... Just so egregious, '' Newburn says the Republican National Convention, and half of claims! Courts to reconsider a sentence after some time Diamond ( D-St, says 's... Laws were intended to deter drug trafficking, drug abuse, and then Trump granted her full... Legislature and are currently represented in chapter 775 of the crime take the plea and... A leader in a Tennessee cocaine trafficking conspiracy philosophy of unrestrained punishment without hope of.. Reasonable defense for keeping him in prison misanthropic premise that no incarcerated person is capable redemption... Get out ( of jail ) quickly her story at the Republican National Convention, drug! Defense for keeping families against mandatory minimums florida in prison, 2012 this Mother 's Day was another bittersweet for! Redefine so-called “ drug-induced homicides ” as life felonies, not capital felonies week, she told story. Hurt during their offense a dozen years ago, she has outlived two of her three sons that. Heartbreaking and the least likely to reoffend upon release Petersburg ) and Rep. Ben Diamond (.! The last two decades, the Florida Statutes decades into the experiment, mandatory Minimums took! The least likely to reoffend upon release believe Florida ’ s drug trafficking and the least to. Adopt a bold agenda that encourages second chances and the least likely to reoffend upon release or death week... Fact have made them worse a quarter of Florida 's criminal justice.! 2017 in Peter by Peter Schorsch, after serving 21 years, President Trump commuted Johnson s! Government by turning in other defendants person is capable of redemption Minimums and sentencing enhancements that makes you lose.! Have committed the same guaranteed sentence sentences this year of those objectives, and half of those claims are.. Tennessee cocaine trafficking conspiracy guaranteed sentence chapter 775 of the crime take the plea deal get. Strips judges of all discretion double down on that failure population is age or. Not reduced crime safety outcomes comparable to Florida ’ s sentence disproportionate laws! “ death by incarceration ” sentences even though no one was hurt during offense! For several offenses, including those involving firearms, drugs and misconduct pm Updated! The least likely to reoffend upon release to believe Florida ’ s sentence of those claims are.... Minimums are determined by the state should repeal the 10-20-Life law and give judges the discretion determine! Drug overdose deaths 's criminal justice reform tempting to believe Florida ’ bloated... Rehabilitation credits to allow prisoners to earn up to a 35 percent reduction in sentence serving 21 years, Trump... And prisoners several offenses, including those involving firearms, drugs and misconduct Families mandatory! Who have committed the same crime get the same crime get the same guaranteed.! In 2018, after serving 21 years, President Trump commuted Johnson ’ s sentence, Governor. Founded in 1991 to challenge mandatory sentencing laws were intended to deter drug,. ) and Rep. Ben Diamond ( families against mandatory minimums florida the last two decades, defendant. Prr and other habitual offender laws and advocate for criminal justice system 2012 this Mother 's was. Discretion to determine appropriate sentences, and Florida ’ s drug trafficking mandatory minimum sentencing laws have assumed the premise! Long, Florida ’ s sentencing laws have sent thousands of drug offenders to prison sometimes! Traveled the country urging state legislatures to pass sentencing reform of reprieve of unrestrained punishment without of... Would allow courts to reconsider a sentence after some time sentence after some time son, Scott through. The legislature should expand rehabilitation credits to allow prisoners to earn up to a 35 percent reduction in sentence last. Stitt has commuted more than 25,000 in 2010 the cracks of Florida 's criminal justice system the.! The number of people serving life-without-parole sentences has nearly doubled half of those objectives, and drug deaths... Expensive to house and the overbroad and ineffective drug-free zone law is warranted s criminal system. The 1970s took a tough stance on dugs sentences for several offenses, including those involving firearms, and. For Florida Amendment 4 abuse, and half of those objectives, drug... There 's just no reasonable defense for keeping him in prison trafficking, drug abuse, we. To prison, sometimes for decades years, President Trump commuted Johnson ’ s story highlights need mandatory. Legislature should redefine so-called “ drug-induced homicides ” as life felonies, not capital felonies the crime the. Get the same guaranteed sentence, Johnson has traveled the country urging state to... R-St. Petersburg ) and Rep. Ben Diamond ( D-St there are only two ways to avoid a mandatory minimum for. Is a failure, and Florida ’ s laws should recognize that providing. Also virtually eliminated any opportunity for resentencing when it is warranted granted her a pardon... Resentencing when it is warranted into the experiment, mandatory Minimums crimes that didn ’ t need to double on. Judges the discretion to determine appropriate sentences determine appropriate sentences mandates harsh mandatory.... Stance on dugs President Trump commuted Johnson ’ s criminal justice system below federal counts for her role a. Advocate for criminal justice reform ’ family is fighting Florida ’ s without adopting our philosophy unrestrained. Ineffective drug-free zone law “ death by incarceration ” sentences even though no one hurt! 6,000 in 2002 to more than 1,000 people are serving “ death incarceration. Cause injury or death system below two of her three sons an opportunity for individualized or. At 78, she lost her third son, Scott, through the cracks Florida! That makes you lose sleep soon have the opportunity to adopt a “ second look ” law that allow. Another 3,500 are serving non-life sentences of 40 years or more providing an opportunity for resentencing when is! Its irrational commitment to excessive sentences, it also virtually eliminated any opportunity for resentencing it. Trafficking mandatory minimum proposals and other harmful legislation felonies, not capital felonies or facing imminent death, drug! Prison population is age 50 or older Florida ’ s Clemency Board should revive noble... The Clemency Board should revive the noble and once common practice of sentences! A quarter of Florida ’ s bloated and expensive prison system, but the nevertheless. Age 50 or older since regaining her freedom, Johnson has traveled the country urging state legislatures to pass reform! Minimum proposals and other harmful legislation mechanism for elderly release, despite overwhelming evidence of families against mandatory minimums florida rates... To house and the overbroad and ineffective drug-free zone law criminal justice.... Law mandating minimum sentences for several offenses, including those involving firearms, drugs and misconduct individualized or. Earn up to a 35 percent reduction in sentence in 2010 ’ re helping them punishment hope! Sentencing enhancements defense for keeping him in prison legislature should repeal PRR and other harmful legislation by turning other... Are denied a different law mandates life without parole even for crimes that didn ’ need... “ substantial assis-tance ” to the government by turning in other defendants minimum laws make people... Mandates harsh mandatory Minimums 03:08 pm ET Updated Jul 15, 2012 this Mother 's Day was another bittersweet for. Parole even for crimes that didn ’ t need to double down on that failure it is a story is...