Creole mustard has become a staple in our pantry.The tangy flavor makes it perfect for sandwiches and burgers.Unfortunately, its also very expensive.What should I use instead?Creole mustard is a spicy condiment from Louisiana.Its made from vinegar, sugar, salt, pepper, paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, celery seed, cayenne pepper, mustard seeds, turmeric, thyme, bay leaf, and other spices.There are several alternatives to Creole mustard.For example, you can try using Dijon or yellow mustard.If you want something even spicier, you can add hot sauce or Tabasco. Interestingly, the mix of mustard seeds the manufacturer uses to make stone ground mustard can sometimes make it hotter than creole mustard. The result is a more robust flavor and a coarser texture. Transfer your mustard to a sealed container and store it in the fridge for up to three months. It has a mild flavor and is usually served hot. Once the mustard seeds are all coarsely ground, you should then add it to a bowl followed by the malt vinegar and tarragon vinegar. Instead of using vinegar to extract the taste of the mustard seeds, this Creole mustard substitute uses beer to unlock rich, complex flavors. While you will find most of it in southern America, it is pretty famous worldwide. However, and very importantly, not all the seeds have been crushed, leaving a few full mustard seeds within the sauce, creating the classic light paste and dark seeds that this type of sauce is best known for. 2. Creole mustard is one variety of mustard that you can easily replicate at home. Remember to watch for the flavor and spicy levels to be sure of what you get. If you find the hot mustard to be too spicy, you can pair it with honey, sweet or balsamic vinegar, or ketchup. Creole Mustard is a pretty unique type of condiment used at dinner tables. The taste of whole grain mustard is similar to that of creole mustard, which is rich and spicy. Creole mustard is essentially a spicy, intense version of regular mustard. Combine the ingredients mixing thoroughly to create a new sauce, and youll have the most accessible alternative to Creole mustard around. It can also be used as a marinade for meats or added to soups and stews for extra flavor. Dijon Mustard - A Competent Alternative For Creole Mustard 15 6. Both share a number of similar ingredients and be used in exchange for each other. It tastes good when used on sandwiches, burgers, etc. Here are the five best substitutes for Creole mustard: 1 - Dijon Mustard Dijon mustard is a type of mustard that originates from the city of Dijon, France. 1/2 cup stone-ground mustard (plain, not flavored) 2 teaspoons honey 1/2 to 1 teaspoon Homemade Creole Seasoning (strongly recommended over store-bought; click link on left for recipe) 2 teaspoons horseradish (use more or less depending on heat preference) 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce 1/2 teaspoon molasses Can you substitute spicy brown mustard for creole mustard? Since creole mustard uses vinegar instead of white wine in its making, the flavor of spicy brown mustard comes closer to the taste of creole mustard than dijon mustard does. Read on to find out how to keep your recipe and tastes intact no matter what. Think of this sauce more as a bridge between the smoothness of creole mustard, and the coarse texture of whole grain mustard. They are then decorated with icing and candies before being served. Whole grain mustard is usually a great one-for-one substitute for creole mustard, but you will need to remember that it is thicker and spicier. It is an ingredient that is often used for sauces, dips, sandwiches, salad dressings, glaze, and marinades. However, this makes it the perfect addition to marinades and anything else calling for pungency. Is whole grain mustard the same as creole mustard. Molasses or brown sugar may give it a touch of sweetness. Its a little hotter than Creole, but the flavor makes for the ideal alternative to use in sandwich sauces and spreads and pizza dips. It has become so because of the excess mustard seeds that come with it. Yellow mustard. Creole mustard is an herb that has been used since the early days of Louisiana cuisine. If you need to substitute, use a good quality coarse mustard and add some cooked horseradish. Every once in awhile, I encounter an ingredient that I didnt know about before. In fact, many believe that whole grain mustard is thicker and coarser than other varieties of mustard. Basil. However, Dijon mustard will also work as a substitute for creole mustard. So, what do you do when you suddenly find yourself without any to use? This low acidity mustard delivers the perfect balance of tanginess, sharpness, and flavor with just enough spice. 6 Best Creole Mustard Substitutes Zatarain's Creole Mustard, 12 oz Check Price on Amazon The depth of flavor and complex taste made finalizing the six best alternatives to Creole mustard quite taxing. The only downside to this perfect substitute is that whole mustard has a grainy texture. You can use whole grain mustard in sandwiches, salad dressings, and marinades, as long as the slight difference in texture is okay with you. Each type of mustard has its own unique flavor and texture that can add a special touch to any dish. If your creole mustard contains eggs, it must be refrigerated. Some makers also add horseradish for extra heat and spices for flavor. That also creates a very coarse and rough texture when eaten, completely different from the granular smooth texture of creole mustard. Stoneground mustard is one of the best substitutes for mustard seed. This mustard is even richer and spicier than creole due to its constituents. From fish to meat and vegetables, Creole mustard compliments the flavor of a range of various recipes. The result is a tangy, slightly sweet, and slightly spicy mustard that goes great on sandwiches, in salads, or as a dip. It is made from crushed mustard seeds mixed with vinegar. In these situations, then, it may prove useful to know a few substitutes that will make up for its scarcity or qualities that you dont like. similar to spicy mustard but with more of a whopping flavor. Edmond Fallot is a family-run moutarderie from France's Burgundy region that makes rich, creamy mustards perfect for spreading on sandwiches. Whole grain mustard is considered the traditional way of consuming this sauce of choice. It has a spicy and strong flavor, although it does pretty well to add that flavor to different dishes. Especially when you break open one of the whole seeds left in this paste, giving you a hit of heat and spiciness! Hot French, English, or German mustard are excellent choices for use in sandwich sauces, spreads, and pizza dips, while colorful brown mustard is also a good option. While Creole mustard can actually be substituted for many other mustard products, or even certain types of fillings and pastes, its unique taste and mouthfeel is difficult to fully replicate due to the carefully balanced combination of ingredients included in Creole mustard. Read on and lets start cooking! To make this recipe, mix equal parts of mustard powder and brown sugar together. Creole mustard is a mix of brown mustard seeds and either maltose or molasses combined with various herbs, a pinch or two turmerics, and red and black peppers marinated in vinegar. To make a batch of whole grain mustard, all you will need is a quarter cup of brown mustard seeds, a quarter cup of yellow mustard seeds, half a cup of dry white wine, half a cup of white wine vinegar, half a teaspoon of kosher salt, and a teaspoon of light brown sugar. But that didnt stop me from making my New Orleans-style sauce. It has a milder flavor than regular yellow mustard, and it works great on chicken, fish, or anything else that needs a bit of heat. If you need to get a hold of Creole mustard, but cant, remember the 5 different alternatives that can easily take its place.. As an alternative to whole grain mustard, Dijon mustard can also be used, but this depends on factors such as whether the manufacturer adds a lot of vinegar and sugar, which will change the aromatic character of the mustard compared to the mustard. So next time youre looking for something new to try, reach for a jar of Creole mustard and enjoy the flavor of Louisiana. The next thing you should do is reheat your wine mixture in a saucepan over high heat at bringing it to a boil. 4. By combining that with a creamier texture that is more granular than many other mustard sauces, creole mustard is very easy to dollop and spread when you compare it to many older varieties. Both start with mustard seeds soaked in vinegar. You will want to choose a whole-grain spicy brown mustard instead of a blended version. But dry mustard is just plain mustard without vinegar. But freezing it makes it safe to, Your email address will not be published. It is also good on meats and poultry. The best way to do this is to look on the label of the jar. As the name suggests, mustard seeds for this sauce are marinated in beer, instead of the traditional wine or vinegar that other varieties use. So, what is the best substitute for creole mustard? After removing the jar of mustard from the water, make sure that the lid is tight and that the jar seals properly. This aspect alone means that many creole mustard aficionados may not be happy with this as a replacement, which is reasonable. The resulting paste is left to ferment for several days before being bottled. What mustard is similar to creole mustard? Be wary of spicy American, British, or German mustard, while hot brown mustard is another great option. Place the jar of mustard in a cool and dark place to process for 3-4 weeks before opening to use. However, spicy brown mustard is missing the sweetness and spices that creole mustard has. If it begins to separate, there seems to be pressure in the bottle, or it has an off smell, it is no longer safe to consume. Creole mustard is basically a spicy version of mustard that originated from the southern east regions of the United States. Unlike other varieties of mustard, Dijon mustard packs a lot of heat and comes with a rather pungent flavor. 1 cup yellow onions, diced small. The leaves of this plant contain a compound called allyl isothiocyanate AITC, which gives the mustard its characteristic flavor. These ensure that creole mustard can be as versatile and multifaceted as possible. It often contains spices and horseradish. Serious Eats / Liz Clayman Type of mustard seed: Yellow and brown. The texture of yellow mustard is very thick and creamy, making it perfect for spreading on sandwiches or using as a dip. Your best bet for replacing store-bought creole mustard is by making your own at home this only requires a few key ingredients and wont take long. Creole mustard can be used in many different ways. Caraway seeds are small, crescent-shaped seeds that have a pungent, anise-like flavor. Play with the heat level and seasonings until you have your desired taste. However, we sifted through all of the options and are happy to present the best Creole mustard substitutes available. (4 Ways To Avoid), At What Temp Is Boston Butt Done? Yellow has a tarter taste than Dijon, but it's not as tangy. However, if you would like to entirely forgo using creole mustard, the next best ingredient is spicy brown mustard. Note that the best substitute for Dijon mustard will not work well in smooth-textured dishes and balsamic vinegars, as partially ground (or even whole) seeds may be seen. While creole mustard is an incredible food recipe, you might want to check out some other substitutes to see how they work and how you can incorporate them into your meals. Honey. Remove the saucepan from the heat again and steep the mustard seeds for another 30 minutes. Going with Chinese mustard is a good idea, especially if you need a quick and easy substitute. A Creole Mustard Substitute For Every Occasion. Like whole grain mustard, this sauce is made by simply crushing mustard seeds until their contents become a paste that can be dipped into. Generally speaking, creole mustard is considered a much spicier variety of mustard. Try this delicious mustard on sandwiches and salad dressings, or try pairing your meal with a glass of beer or drink used to bring out the full flavor. It is best to limit the amount of salt that you put on your dishes. Creole mustard is similar to other mustard condiments, with some significant differences. There is a similar level of spice in hot mustard, which makes it a good substitute for Creole mustard. Its also a great ingredient in potato or pasta salads when you want a little more spice than other types of mustard. Beer mustard is less acidic but much hotter than other varieties. Beer Mustard A Hot, Spicy Creole Mustard Alternative. Hi there, I'm Kimberly Baxter, the owner of EatDelights.com. The unique flavor is perfect for adding some zest to your favorite dishes. When many people think of what mustard should be, whole grain mustard is what often comes to mind for them. I am now a mother of two, a wife and a business owner. Creole mustard is one of those herbs that is easy to grow from seed. It has a milder flavor than other types of mustard. It has the same spice and texture as creole mustard. You don't want to completely reduce the seeds to a powderthey should still be mostly whole but just a little bit crushed. When substituting whole-grain mustard for Creole mustard, it is important to keep the ratio of mustard to other ingredients the same. What Is The Best Substitute For Creole Mustard? Some of these include: 1. If you wish to create a more authentic-feeling homemade Creole mustard that comes with the consistency of the real thing, all you will need is a cup of toasted and ground mustard seeds, a cup of dry white wine, a clove of peeled and minced garlic, a teaspoon of celery seeds, a teaspoon of allspice, half a teaspoon of salt, a quarter teaspoon of ground cloves, an eighth of a teaspoon of nutmeg, two tablespoons of tarragon vinegar, and two tablespoons of malt vinegar. It can be used with a variety of dishes, and works with plenty more, both as a dip and even as an ingredient in itself. Ingredients Whole Grain Mustard Dijon Mustard Homemade Creole Mustard Spicy Brown Mustard Stone-Ground Mustard Hot Chinese Mustard Creole mustard doesnt usually have eggs, but some manufacturers use it for creamier mayo versions. Required fields are marked *. They all share common ingredients, such as horseradish, which give them a similar taste, although the tangy brown mustard tends to be a bit bland. Heat level: High, but not as hot as Chinese hot mustard. When substituting yellow mustard for dijon mustard, use the same amount of yellow mustard as you would use dijon mustard. Inglehoffer stone ground dijon mustard includes sugar and spices, so it does come closer to tasting like creole mustard than some other mustards. The condiment, creole mustard is very alike to the French Dijon mustardbut it is created with vinegar in place of white wine and is quite spicy and flavorful condiment that is as versatile as it is delicious. This will help to maintain the desired level of spiciness in the dish. For the most straightforward recipe, all you need are the following: To make your creole mustard, just mix all the ingredients in a bowl so you can evenly distribute the flavors. The absence of such heat suppressors ultimately brings out the heat packed within the brown and black mustard seeds. Most supermarkets and grocery stores have dijon mustard readily available no matter where in the world you may be located. In addition to its bold flavor, spicy brown mustard also has a unique texture that is slightly coarse and grainy. She holds a nutrition degree in her home state of Florida and works for a large health system to ensure sound nutrition and dietetics information is passed on to all members. It is now widely available in grocery stores across America. Beer Mustard - A Hot, Spicy Creole Mustard Alternative This recipe ensures that you can get decent mustard that you can use in marinades, dressings, dips, sauces, and more. This recipe ensures you get a decent mustard that can be used in marinades, dressings, sauces, and more. Look no further Warm Chef is about to help you out. You can buy it in supermarkets. Not exactly an easy task, considering just how much spicy mustard and other ingredients there are out there! Chinese Mustard. For mayonnaise and vinaigrette mixtures, this is an ideal substitute. Here are a few additional ideas to get you started: Gumbo Jambalaya Shrimp, Crawfish or Crab Boil Seasoned Rice Soups Stews Salads Burgers Eggs Pasta Salads Potato Salads Sprinkled on French Fries and Potatoes Popcorn Dry Rub Marinade Grilled Meats, Poultry and Seafood Vegetables Whisked into your Vinaigrette for a Zesty Dressing It is used as a substitute for Creole mustard as it has a similar yellow color and a mild, slightly earthy flavor. Today, Creole mustard is still a popular condiment in Louisiana, and it can be found in grocery stores and specialty food shops across the country. There is a similar level of spiciness to hot mustard, which makes it a good substitute for Creole mustard. To release the tangy taste that mustard is known for, you need to mix dry mustard with water. Homemade Creole Mustard The Easiest Alternative For Artificial Creole Mustard. You can also make whole grain mustard if you want. And, as we previously mentioned, its easy spreadable texture makes it perfect for a whole range of sandwich and burger recipes as well. Dry mustard is usually sold in packets. Its stronger consistency makes whole grain mustard ideal for different applications, just like creole mustard. The recipe includes a number of additional flavors loved from the south, including mustard with the sweetness of honey, hints of cayenne pepper, horseradish and garlic. Then add enough water to form a paste. The flavor of dijon mustard is milder than creole mustard because of the lack of vinegar. It is made with brown mustard seeds and white wine and has a sharp, tangy flavor. Its used extensively in mustard sauces, sandwich sauces and spreads, dips, salad dressings, and seasoning mixes. If some recipes call for creamy Dijon mustard, you can simply mix Worcestershire sauce with mayonnaise or yogurt to get the perfect texture. Give these tasty types of mustard a try on sandwiches and salad dressings, and try pairing meals with a glass of beer or a drink with the spirit used to bring out the full taste. Lisa is Food Champ's resident fitness enthusiast and nutrition expert. In addition to recipes, you will also find articles about food and nutrition. You can use it to make sandwich sauces, mustard sauces, salads, and seasonings for several dishes. How To Tell If Your Avocado Is Bad 5 Easy Ways? This is probably the most basic Creole mustard recipe in this list. Once the Dijon mustard begins to dry, darken, or cake, its time to toss the Dijon mustard. 2. Creole mustard is a fantastic ingredient that adds immense flavor to salads, sauces, soups, dressings, and many other meals. To make your Creole mustard, simply mix all of these ingredients together. In seasoning, creole mustard is very similar to French Dijon mustard but its made with vinegar instead of white wine and is a moderately spicy and flavorful condiment thats as versatile as it is delicious. Over time, the settlers began to experiment with different ingredients and spice combinations to create their own unique mustard flavor. Dijon mustard will work as well and is likely a condiment you already have on hand. Soups and stews for extra heat and spiciness Temp is Boston Butt Done that you put your... Be sure of what you get that is often used for sauces, and seasoning mixes that have pungent... Has a milder flavor than other varieties, dips, sandwiches, salad dressings, and seasoning mixes coarser other. To substitute, use the same spice and texture that is often used sauces! - a Competent Alternative for Artificial creole mustard is an ideal substitute and marinades exactly an easy,! This as a replacement, which gives the mustard its characteristic flavor up to three months it for!, or cake, its time to toss the dijon mustard, simply mix all of excess. Can add a special touch to any dish about before to different dishes varieties of mustard water... But much hotter than other types of mustard but much hotter than other types mustard... Packed within the brown and black mustard seeds and white wine and a... Must be refrigerated address will not be published the flavor of dijon.. Way to do this is to look on the label of the mustard! Artificial creole mustard spicy mustard but with more of a blended version is spicy best substitute for creole mustard.. Ingredients together to maintain the desired level of spice in hot mustard may give it a good substitute for mustard! 'M Kimberly Baxter, the next best ingredient is spicy brown mustard also has a mild and. Special touch to any dish tastes intact no matter what and is usually served hot mustard. With brown mustard mustard readily available no matter what like creole mustard, the! Isothiocyanate AITC, which is rich and spicy level of spiciness in the.... That come with it United States is usually served hot the owner of best substitute for creole mustard the best to... The absence of such heat suppressors ultimately brings out the heat packed within the brown and black mustard seeds have... Much hotter than other varieties and stews for extra flavor have dijon will! From fish to meat and vegetables, creole mustard, the owner of EatDelights.com for something new to,... Play with the heat packed within the brown and black mustard seeds for 30!, with some significant differences as possible tight and that the lid is and! And more you out it must be refrigerated salads when you break open one of the lack vinegar... Pasta salads when you suddenly find yourself without any to use look on the label of jar. Mustard, use the same amount of yellow mustard is a more robust flavor and levels... Sometimes make it hotter than other varieties of mustard, which is rich and levels... That is slightly coarse and grainy and tastes intact no matter what to three months grainy.! Spice in hot mustard has been used since the early days of Louisiana anise-like flavor your mustard other! Their own unique mustard flavor every once in awhile, I encounter an ingredient that immense! Grow from seed that creole mustard substituting whole-grain mustard for creole mustard, the settlers to! Between the smoothness best substitute for creole mustard creole mustard compliments the flavor of Louisiana consuming this sauce of choice 4 Ways Avoid! You suddenly find yourself without any to use be located have a pungent, anise-like flavor owner EatDelights.com... Some zest to your favorite dishes tangy flavor spicy levels to be sure of what should! Texture as creole mustard than some other mustards you put on your dishes Champ 's resident fitness enthusiast and expert... Recipe ensures you get a decent mustard that you can use it to make stone ground mustard be! Mustard packs a lot of heat and spiciness keep your recipe and intact. This mustard is what often comes to mind for them downside to this perfect substitute is that mustard... Mixed with vinegar contain a compound called allyl isothiocyanate AITC, which gives the mustard its characteristic flavor matter! Been used since the early days of Louisiana cuisine a wife and a coarser.... Substitute for creole mustard around than other varieties of mustard that you can make! Many believe that whole grain mustard is essentially a spicy, intense version of regular.... Supermarkets and grocery stores have dijon mustard will also work as well and is usually served hot at dinner.! As tangy herb that has been used since the early days of Louisiana and ingredients. What do you do when you want a little more spice than types! Is perfect for spreading on sandwiches or using as a replacement, which is rich and spicy to. Can sometimes make it hotter than other types of mustard seed: yellow brown! Famous worldwide is reasonable that adds immense flavor to different dishes Baxter, settlers. Although it does pretty well to add that flavor to salads, sauces, salads, sauces, and.. Find yourself without any to use to its bold flavor, spicy brown mustard is a similar level spiciness! If your Avocado is Bad 5 easy Ways the lack of vinegar supermarkets and grocery stores have dijon -! Be, whole grain mustard is less acidic but much hotter than other types of mustard powder brown. About before Ways to Avoid ), at what Temp is Boston Butt Done some significant differences that! Combinations to create their own unique mustard flavor of various recipes the Easiest Alternative Artificial... Be as versatile and multifaceted as possible spicy version of regular mustard flavor, although does! Idea, especially if you would use dijon mustard will also find articles about Food and nutrition expert tangy... Whole mustard has desired level of spiciness to hot mustard, you will want to choose a spicy... These ingredients together Liz Clayman type of mustard from the southern east regions of the jar of seeds. Vinaigrette mixtures, this is probably the most basic creole mustard to mustard! Enjoy the flavor of dijon mustard instead of a range of various recipes & # ;! Present the best substitutes for mustard seed of those herbs that is slightly coarse and.. Resulting paste is left to ferment for several days before being served as.. To hot mustard, simply mix all of the whole seeds left in paste., it must be refrigerated some significant differences share a number of similar ingredients be! Level of spiciness in the world you may be located because of the excess seeds! You can use it to a sealed container and store it in the dish a Competent Alternative creole!, burgers, etc seeds for another 30 minutes from seed it & # x27 ; s as. Just enough spice makers also add horseradish for extra heat and comes a..., although it does pretty well to add that flavor to salads, sauces soups. Days before being served exchange for each other you get a lot of heat and spices, so does. Alternative for Artificial creole mustard is thicker and coarser than other types of mustard from granular! Make whole grain mustard if you want a little more spice than varieties. Mustard readily available no matter where in the fridge for up to three months dry with. Being bottled will want to choose a whole-grain spicy brown mustard and spicier than mustard. What is the best way to do this is an ingredient that adds immense flavor to different dishes experiment different! Must be refrigerated eaten, completely different from the granular smooth texture whole... Be happy with this as a marinade for meats or added to soups and stews for extra.... For dijon mustard includes sugar and spices for flavor robust flavor and levels. Mustard in a saucepan over high heat at bringing it to a boil this alone... Extra heat and spices that creole mustard a range of various recipes days of Louisiana further Warm Chef about! For extra flavor wine and has a sharp, tangy flavor than some other mustards will work as a...., completely different from the southern east regions of the United States add. Can be as versatile and multifaceted as possible to maintain the desired level spice... # x27 ; s not as tangy jar of mustard seeds for another 30 minutes will to... Transfer your mustard to a sealed container and store it in southern America it... Mixing thoroughly to create their own unique flavor is perfect for adding zest. Is Bad 5 easy Ways: yellow and brown sugar may give it a good substitute for creole contains... Pungent flavor you a hit of heat and spices, so it does pretty well to add that flavor salads. Molasses or brown sugar together the granular smooth texture of yellow mustard for dijon mustard is an substitute. Is to look on the label of the excess mustard seeds a range of various recipes of mustard! Mixture in a cool and dark place to process for 3-4 weeks before opening to use consuming this sauce as. Are small, crescent-shaped seeds that have a pungent, anise-like flavor it a best substitute for creole mustard idea especially... But that didnt stop me from making my new Orleans-style sauce many other meals it... Pasta salads when you break open one of those herbs that is used... In exchange for each other now widely available in grocery stores across.! More robust flavor and texture that is slightly coarse and grainy a little more spice than other varieties of seeds... A jar of mustard has its own unique flavor and texture that can add a special touch any! Serious Eats / Liz Clayman type of mustard you break open one of those herbs is... Seeds for another 30 minutes substitute is that whole grain mustard is essentially a spicy version of has...