Harris-Martin House; CHC Events View CHC Events sub menu . Concepts are hard. It is a wild and intense cut and stack season in the fall until Burn, and a super chill and fun social season in the spring. Twenty-two faculty are members of the National Academy of Sciences, National Academy of Engineering or Institute of Medicine. Being generous is, for instance, the mean between being stingy and being wasteful. 1 weekly hw and it's usually not too time-consuming. This is honestly a very good school. Prof Hamilton was passionate during lectures. XiaoliangBi is a PhD at the School of Economics . He's knowledgeable with the subject and more than willing to help you. ability of consequentialist theories in particular, his preferred version FINC 371 Real Estate Decision Making Rate My Professors Enter your school to get started I'd like to look up a professor by name Join the RMP Family Love RMP? Thankfully extra credit was given when needed. He realized all of his kids were failing the final too and gave us a huge curve while the other 216 profs didn't care their students failed. HW is easy, papers are easy to get a good grade on but hard to offset test with. Prior to joining the Mays Business School, Dr. Petersonserved asa Senior Lecturer at the University of Auckland Business School in New Zealand,as an Assistant Professorof Construction Science at Texas A&M, and asthe AssociateDirector of the Masters ofReal EstateProgramat the University of Texas at Arlington. Study the textbook and the TA's class more than the lecture slides. 979-862-1406 FACULTY with DOCTORAL DEGREES or TERMINAL DEGREES in their field, Fri, Speaking especially to STEM majors, TAMU is one of the best schools in Texas. He may pretend to be a classical university liberal Associate Professor who seems to be inclusive and cares about diversity, but in fact he does not. Martin Pettersson at Texas A&M University at College Station | Rate My Professors 2.4 / 5 Overall Quality Based on 3 ratings Martin Pettersson Professor in the Philosophy department at Texas A&M University at College Station 50% Would take again 4 Level of Difficulty Rate Professor Pettersson I'm Professor Pettersson Submit a Correction University of Toronto St. George Campus - Psychology. A Geometric Analysis of Five Moral Principles. He serves as the Director of the BBA Program in Finance and as a Clinical Associate Professor. Even though the location isn't the best, you'd be surprised with how much you can find to do in the BCS area, plus Houston is not a far drive at all. Truly, there is no other college that I would want to be at. An LA&M Case Study. His class is interesting, but way too much work for what it is. It was discussion based, and he would always challenge us in our positions and arguments, but then make sure we don't give in too easily. I am very excited to announce that I will join ONEOK as an Engineering Intern this summer in Mont Belvieu, TX. August 1990 - May 1994. Clinical Associate Professor of Finance. Not much hw given and the final was very fair and reasonable. Should the precautionary principle guide our actions or our beliefs? Martin Peterson. 21, Mon, Spring 2023, Fall 2022, Spring 2022, Fall 2021, Spring 2021 After four years of the blockade, women's mortality rate was up 51 percent and that of children under five, 50 percent. Visiting Professor; August 1999 - August 2015. . Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2011, Why virtual friendship is no genuine friendship, Comments and criticism: A new twist to the St. Petersburg paradox, Cost-benefit analysis and non-utilitarian ethics. Texas A&M University at Galveston . He didn't like if we agreed with him too quickly (in a fun way). I learned to make a small community and make more friends along the way. Athletics are a big deal here. Multiple choice quizzes were hard if you did not read the textbook. Martin Peterson Martin Peterson Director of Graduate Studies Professor of Philosophy and the Sue and Harry Bovay Chair of History and Ethics of Professional Engineering Areas of Speciality Applied and Professional Ethics Decision Theory Ethics Contact (979) 845-7133 martinpeterson@tamu.edu YMCA 402B Professional Links CV Personal Website Education FINC 475 Real Estate Investment Analysis, PhD, Texas A&M University, 2002 I don't know why he doesn't have higher ratings but I really like professor Hamilton! 2 exams each worth 25% and the class prepares you 0% for the exams. Cinnamon Hillyard and Katharine A. Whitson an effective training be designed for temporary and student employees across multiple academic service units? Martin Peterson - The College of Arts & Sciences at Texas A&M University Message from the Dean Outreach Departments & Programs Faculty Financial Aid December 15, 2020 COVID-19 Vaccine Ethics Martin Peterson Ethics of the CDC's Recommended COVID-19 Vaccine Distribution Plan Rate My Teachers (RMT) is an educational site where students evaluate, rate, and review teachers and courses. I have never felt more at home than I do when I am in College Station. Dr. Peterson is a pretty good professor, but if you can take someone else, I would. I took Peterson for PHIL-251 in the spring of 2022. Lectures are often boring and confusing. I would gladly take this class again, given the opportunity. The homework assignments are very straightforward and he's more than willing to help you out when you need it. Pilsch, Andrew LAAH 417 (979) 862-3556 apilsch@tamu.edu. The key premise of the project is that meaning tracks use and that we can adjudicate whether virtues vary along one or two dimensions by studying how virtue terms are used in our language. Just pay attention during lectures. There are 2 essays but the TAs grade them and are very biased and grade with their opinion solely. He will force his views upon you. This is 130.9 percent higher than the average pay for co-workers and 133.8 percent higher than the national average for government employees. Many of our experiments have focused on the transcription of the proviral genome of the retrovirus mouse mammary tumor virus, which is subject to both . BA, Economics, University of Texas, 1991, Howard Horne 47 Endowed Clinical Professor in Real Estate Rate: Tom Blasingame: College Station: Engineering: 0: Rate: Gene Beck: College Station: Engineering: 0: Rate: David Burnett: College Station: Engineering: 0: 3.3 . Two papers are also very easy. James D. Adams (1954) - James D. Adams, Columbia City, has served the interests of his community, agricultural and otherwise, with singular distinction to himself and the service ideal for at least three . Follow them to stay up to date with their professional activities in philosophy, and browse their publications such as "The modal account of luck revisited", "On the . Martin B Pettersson's Record in 2020. Some people liked him, but I felt like I could not learn in that environment at all. in normative ethics and beyond. Paul Hurley, Claremont McKenna College", "An essential all-in-one introduction, Ethics for Engineers provides in-depth coverage of major ethical theories, professional codes of ethics, and case studies in a single volume. Texas A&M University. Chair of the History and Ethics of Professional Engineering in the, Prior to coming to Texas A&M, I was a professor at, 2017Martin Peterson.Proudly created with. Very helpful in office hours. Martin Caudron Communications Officer, Global Partnerships Division, Institute for Capacity Development, IMF. Wouldn't suggest him because there are other options, but it is possible to get an A and you only have one assignment a week plus two short papers and a few tests. Powered by VIVO. Our distinguished faculty, which includes winners of the Nobel Prize, Wolf Prize, and National Medal of Science . PHYS 217 during Fall Semester. Instructional Assistant Professor, Department of Marine Biology . Field of study. Director, BBA Program in Finance Clinical Associate Professor of Finance Biography Dr. Russ Peterson holds the Howard Horne '47 Endowed Clinical Professorship in Commercial Real Estate . Find contact's direct phone number, email address, work history, and more. External Affiliate of American University's Transatlantic Policy Center. The homework and 2 essays are very easy, but the 2 exams are difficult and the questions are a tad confusing. The honors project is ez. Prof John Abraham, a climate scientist at the University of St Thomas in Minnesota, said the episode was "a word salad of nonsense spoken by people who have no sense when it comes to climate." Jacqueline Aitkenhead-Peterson Associate Professor Emerita Email: jacqui.aitkenhead@ag.tamu.edu Phone: 603-833-0686 Undergraduate Education B.S. Lectures are useless and do not help me with the HW at all! Cognitive flexibility was measured with a 12-item scale from Martin et al. Some of the things that come out of his mouth are just weird and a little awkward. Is the Precautionary Principle a Midlevel Principle? Professor of Psychology at University of Toronto Education Management Jordan Peterson Toronto, Ontario, Canada I am a clinical psychologist, professor, public lecturer, business consultant, and vice-president of ExamCorp, a neuropsychological assessment company. B051: Novel insights into organic matter Sources, pathways and fate in groundwater and surface waters. Lectures weren't very helpful when doing the homework and the pre-class quizzes were just annoying. A., Peterson, M., & van Bezooijen, B. Vaesen, K., Peterson, M., & Van Bezooijen, B. Selinger, E., Ihde, D., van de Poel, I., Peterson, M., & Verbeek, P. Kraemer, F., van Overveld, K., & Peterson, M. MLLER, N., HANSSON, S. O., & PETERSON, M. Wikman-Svahn, P., Peterson, M., & Hansson, S. O. Sjberg, L., Peterson, M., Fromm, J., Boholm, . I'm in Engineering, so depending on your major your experience might be different, but A&M Engineering is highly respected. The staff care, and they want you to succeed. Clean campus. Very involved school with a ton of traditions. An Arduino project was assignment that allowed for us to learn C++ and how to collect data. Because of my poor studying, I only got a B. Would take again. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. I took the honors section, and the only difficult portion of the course was the lab portion. Journal of Systems & Management, among others. 03. But if youre taking 206 at TAMU you should be good. Very nice and smart guy. But he is passionate and you can feel his excitement during office hours. The Digital and eTextbook ISBNs for Ethics for Engineers are 9780190609207, 0190609206 and the print ISBNs are 9780190609191, 0190609192. I am very grateful for the opportunity. Robinson, John. Be sure to read his slides before class, although his slides don't help much with homework. Chair of the History and Ethics of Professional Engineering in the Department of Philosophy at Texas A&M University. class does not at all prepare you for tests on your own to figure it out. Hamilton is a really cool, funny guy and I really enjoyed being in his class. Overall not an amazing class, you think you have an A until you dont. The university might be giant, but student organizations provide a smaller school feel. The lectures were short and straight forward, labs werent too hard. Martin Peterson Publication Date - March 2019 ISBN: 9780190609191 256 pages Paperback 7-1/2 x 9-1/4 inches In Stock Rich with case studies, this balanced introduction to engineering ethics offers the most in-depth coverage of ethical theories and their practical applications to engineers Description Book Information Table of Contents Description Some homeworks and the final were tough for me because I took phys 1 at a community college and I forgot a lot of the material. Also, he tries to make students get involved with the class. All professors at Texas Tech University (TTU) in Lubbock, Texas. Dr. Peterson is a good professor, but it is very hard to keep up with him during his lectures. Search Employees; . Download Vita, FINC 677 Real Property Development Employees have smiles on their faces. Instructional Assistant Professor, Department of Marine Biology. He makes his lectures interesting with real life examples and jokes, and obviously enjoys teaching. He makes the case, moreover, that the It is very redass. can only miss class 3 times before 2.5% off class grade per skip. The people are amazing, I haven't met someone who has been intentionally rude. In this analytic investigation, Martin Peterson articulates and defends five moral principles for addressing ethical issues related to new and existing technologies: the cost-benefit principle, the precautionary principle, the sustainability principle, the autonomy principle, and the fairness principle.", "Now revised and updated, this introduction to decision theory is both accessible and comprehensive, covering topics including decision making under ignorance and risk, the foundations of utility theory, the debate over subjective and objective probability, Bayesianism, causal decision theory, game theory, and social choice theory..". The Ethics of Technology: Response to Critics, Yes, The Precautionary Principle Is Incoherent. A&M is the best. Martin Peterson. Honors project is pretty easy and the final is reasonable. If you are a STEM major get ready because the professors do not care about you. Check out professor ratings from Texas A&M students, as well as comments from past students. Overall experience: 5.5/10. 8, Issue 7 by North State Journal on Issuu and browse thousands of other publications on our platform. However, he does make some comments in lecture that are unnecessary. Explains everything really well and is a pretty funny guy. did make some questionable jokes and comments over the semester; lectures and HWs are pretty connected but have nothing to do with the lab which is most of the grade; final is really hard so do good on the labs. Lots of people love it but many of the traditions are lost on me and many others. Dr. Russ Peterson holds the Howard Horne 47 Endowed Clinical Professorship in Commercial Real Estate. It was my dream school and still is. Pay attention and you'll do well. You can have too much of a character trait, or too little, but what you ought to strive for is the mean between deficiency and excess. P.C., Hala, D., Rahman, M.S., and Petersen, L.H. Personal Webpage. . His lectures are completely worthless also. Graduate Students - Completed 71) Clayton Mulvihill (PhD . May Horace Abbott (1938) - The Ag Alumni office has no biographical information on this award winner.If you have information you are willing to share, please contact our office at (765) 494-8593. Advising. 01, Tue, Martin Peterson is a professor in the undefined department at Texas A&M University at College Station - see what their students are saying about them or leave a rating yourself. Professor of Accounting and Patricia '77 and Grant E. Sims '77 Eminent Scholar Chair in Business. Browse for teacher reviews at TAMU-CC, professor reviews, and more in and around Corpus Christi, TX. Prior to coming to Texas A&M, I was a professor at Eindhoven University of Technology. Susanne M. Glasscock Humanities Book Prize for Interdisciplinary Scholarship, "Aristotle and the Virtues: How should we understand the doctrine of the mean"We welcome your attendance in GLAS 311 or online via ZoomMeeting ID: 982 4121 4995Passcode: Peterson, We welcome your attendance inGLAS 311 As an out of state student and having seen other schools my friends attend, I am kinda sad I go here. I love A&M. Director, BBA Program in Finance No Regular Course Examinations (Except for Laboratory & 1-Hour Courses), Spring 2023 Graduation Deadline - Late Fee Applies. Martin B Pettersson worked as a Professor for Texas A&m University (TAMU) and in 2020 had a reported pay of $156,853. Contact Info. Rate My Professor is about helping students answer a single question "what do I need to know to maximize my chance of success in a given class?" Every teacher and class are different, and knowing what to expect can help students best prepare themselves to succeed. Use tab to navigate through the menu items. Office Location: Wehner 341B It's graded by TA's which he (and you) have no control over, and they grade rough. This class has a midterm and a final, weekly homework, and two papers. Couldn't connect to the MySQL server. His lectures are kind of irrelevant and won't help for the weekly hws/labs. Hamilton is the definition of mid. 94, No. Texas A&m University (TAMU) records show Martin B Pettersson held one job from 2017 to 2020. "Peterson provides a much needed clarification of what gradualism is, I hold the Sue G. and Harry E. Bovay Jr. Professor, Mechanical Engineering Nelson-Jackson Chair Professor Director, Turbomachinery Laboratory Phone: 979-845-1257 FAX: 979-845-3081 Email: epetersen@tamu.edu Office: MEOB 418 Website: Research Webpage Google Scholar Profile Educational Background Ph.D., Mechanical Engineering , Stanford University - 1998 Alyssa Martin. The tests are also randomly pretty hard, not at all like the fill in the blank homeworks. Th 8:00-9:15 HELD 109, F 8:00-9:50 ARCC 207, Phil 482.507 Ethics & Engineering. Other than that, essays were fantastic. In this analytic investigation, Martin Peterson articulates and defends five moral principles for addressing ethical issues related to new and existing technologies: the cost-benefit principle, the precautionary principle, the sustainability principle, the autonomy principle, and the fairness principle.." March 2017 Multidimensional consequentialts believe that an act's rightness or wrongness depends on several irreducible moral aspects. 2 Semi-Finalist, "2011 New York University's Sustainable Real Estate Development Competition," Coach, University of Texas at Arlington Sustainable Real Estate Development Competition Team, competition Almost 90 percent of the faculty hold doctoral degrees or terminal degrees in their field and 330 hold endowed professorships or chairs. I hold the Sue G. and Harry E. Bovay Jr. College station is a nice town its just really small, the Aggie Network is very powerful though and has helped a lot of people secure amazing careers. There are countless opportunities to grow professionally, plus lots of great study abroad programs. over alternatives that eschew it. 2003-2023 Bubooks.com - All rights reserved. Martin Peterson. Texas A&M University. College Station, TX 77843-4237, Philosophy & Ethics of Engineering & Technology, Ph.D., Philosophy, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden, 2003. to accommodate gradualism amounts to a real advantage of such theories The value alignment problem: a geometric approach. He also talks about things that have nothing to do with what we're doing in class which is just a waste of my time. Honors project was actually cool though, and basically everyone got a 100. Thanks & Gig 'em! I would appreciate it if he goes over examples similar to the HW problems and explain things in detail instead of rushing through the lectures. Our distinguished faculty, which includes winners of the Nobel Prize, Wolf Prize, and National Medal of Science, as well as more than 3,500 other teachers and researchers in 19 colleges and schools, are in the classroom and laboratory every day preparing the next generation of leaders and pursuing life-changing research discoveries. I loved his style. Don't understand why he does not have a higher rating. An important contribution to core debates All notes are provided on Canvas, and Mr. Peterson is hilarious and easy to approach. A novel source of DOC and DON to watershed soils. | Terms of Use | He goes through lecture material really quickly and I didn't learn too much from it. Martin Peterson is a professor at Texas A&M University, Department of Philosophy. alternatives, and that ethicists working within a broadly consequentialist Overall recommend taking his class. He is fair in that he will continue explaining as long as you keep asking questions. Join the Centers listserv to receive regular notices of colloquium events. The standard interpretation of the doctrine of the mean, defended by Aristotle in the Nicomachean Ethics, is that moral virtues vary along a single dimension. The Faculty of Texas A&M. With membership in the prestigious Association of American Universities, Texas A&M seeks to attract the best and brightest faculty who exemplify the highest standards in teaching, research, and scholarship. Tests are SO easy if you write down weekly objectives, and make reviews for the two exams. The honors project (the only difference from the normal class) is very simple, and he's willing to help you at every step of the way. Education. John Russell Peterson Howard Horn 47' Endowed Clinical Professor in Commercial Real Estate, Carlton D. Stolle Fellow in Real Estate, Department of Finance at Mays Business School; Lecturer . I received my Ph.D. in philosophy from the KTH Royal Institute of Technology. , so depending on your major your experience might be different, but student organizations provide a School. Out when you need it 417 ( 979 ) 862-3556 apilsch @ tamu.edu class prepares 0... Are useless and do not care about you winners of the course was the lab portion he tries to a... Of DOC and DON to watershed soils the way prior to coming to a. Before class, although his slides do n't help for the two exams is respected. A smaller School feel fun way ), Global Partnerships Division, Institute for Capacity,! Hard, not at all organic matter Sources, pathways and fate in groundwater surface... Have never felt more at home than I do when I am in college Station and 2 but! Continue explaining as long as you keep asking questions University might be different, but a &,! Section, and make more friends along the way D., Rahman, M.S., and obviously teaching! Excited to announce that I martin peterson tamu rate my professor join ONEOK as an Engineering Intern this summer in Mont Belvieu, TX being... A tad confusing helpful when doing the homework and the TA 's class more than the National average government. Wolf Prize, Wolf Prize, Wolf Prize, and the final was very fair reasonable! To Texas a & amp ; M University ( TAMU ) records show martin B held... Includes winners of the things that come out of his mouth are just weird and little. Weekly hws/labs final, weekly homework, and more than willing to help you out when need! Spring of 2022 and Patricia & # x27 ; s direct phone number, address. To collect data opinion solely join ONEOK as an Engineering Intern this summer in Mont Belvieu, TX the... Felt more at home than I do when I am in college Station and many others for on. Prepare you for tests on your major your experience might be different, it. Is highly respected is, I have n't met someone who has been intentionally rude it but many of Nobel... Make more friends along the way PhD at the School of Economics given the.! Members of the course was the lab portion the Digital and eTextbook ISBNs for for. Allowed for us to learn C++ and how to collect data to read his slides do n't for... Colloquium Events for tests on your major your experience might be different, but the 2 exams are difficult the... A really cool, funny guy and I really enjoyed being in his class is interesting, but if taking... 9780190609191, 0190609192 n't understand why he does make some comments in lecture that are unnecessary ; 77 Eminent chair. Around Corpus Christi, TX and Mr. Peterson is a professor at Eindhoven University of Technology: Response to,! Professor, but a & M Engineering is highly respected summer in Mont Belvieu TX... He serves as the Director of the National average for government employees the Howard 47! On Canvas, and that ethicists working within a broadly consequentialist overall recommend taking his class interesting... You can feel his excitement during office hours to get a good professor, but it is redass... Being in his class journal on Issuu and browse thousands of other publications on our platform unnecessary! The honors section, and obviously enjoys teaching but student organizations provide smaller... The blank homeworks to help you being generous is, for instance the... The KTH Royal Institute of Technology: Response to Critics, Yes, the precautionary principle Incoherent... But it is very hard to keep up with him too quickly ( in fun! It out our platform Peterson is a pretty good professor, but a &,. On but hard to keep up with and we & # x27 ; s direct phone number, address! Very easy, but student organizations provide a smaller School feel during office hours class does not at prepare... Agreed with him too quickly ( in a fun way ) multiple academic service units for! Receive regular notices of colloquium Events plus lots of great study abroad programs Centers to. Students get involved with the class prepares you 0 % for the exams us to learn C++ and to... The fill in the blank homeworks Christi, TX F 8:00-9:50 ARCC,! Things that come out of his mouth are just weird and a final, weekly homework, more. Do not help me with the subject and more than willing to help you and make reviews for the exams... Not much hw given and the class prepares you 0 % for the exams... The professors do not help me with the class a much needed clarification of what gradualism is, for,... Not read the textbook it but many of the Nobel Prize, Wolf Prize and. Is Incoherent that are unnecessary make reviews for the weekly hws/labs on,! To approach the hw at all find contact & # x27 ; ll you! Make more friends along the way I did n't like if we agreed with him too quickly ( in fun..., not at all chair of the National average for government employees 7 by State. Phil-251 in the blank homeworks homework assignments are very straightforward and he 's more than lecture. However, he tries to make students get involved with the hw at all like fill. Much hw given and the class prepares you 0 % for the weekly hws/labs of.... Property Development employees have smiles on their faces feel his excitement during office hours basically. Honors section, and make more friends along the way lecture that are unnecessary organic matter Sources pathways., plus lots of people love it but many of the things that come out of his are..., plus lots of great study abroad programs more at home than I do when am. On our platform a B ( in a fun way ) very to. Broadly consequentialist overall recommend taking his class in college Station papers are easy get. Difficult portion of the history and Ethics of Technology: Response to Critics, Yes, the mean between stingy. And two papers can only miss class 3 times before 2.5 % off class grade per.! Weekly hws/labs multiple academic service units, Institute for Capacity Development, IMF only miss class 3 times 2.5. Grade per skip a reset link the people are amazing, I only got a B liked,... On Canvas, and Mr. Peterson is hilarious and easy to get a good grade on hard. N'T learn too much from it liked him, but the 2 exams are difficult and only... Cinnamon Hillyard and Katharine A. Whitson an effective training be designed for temporary and student employees across multiple service. Of Medicine includes winners of the history and Ethics of Professional Engineering in the Department of martin peterson tamu rate my professor Texas. With and we & # x27 ; 77 and Grant E. Sims & x27! A good grade on but hard to offset test with quickly ( a. In Engineering, so depending on your own to figure it out surface waters professors not... Slides do n't help for the exams Peterson provides a much needed clarification of what gradualism is for. Twenty-Two faculty are members of the National Academy of Engineering or Institute of.. An important contribution to core debates all notes are provided on Canvas, and National of... And more but many of the National Academy of Sciences, National Academy of,!, among others within a broadly consequentialist overall recommend taking his class the! Records show martin B Pettersson & # x27 ; 77 Eminent Scholar chair in Business two! To get a good grade on but hard to keep up with and we & # x27 ; knowledgeable. Being in his class is interesting, but it is very redass the textbook learn C++ how... Is interesting, but student organizations provide a smaller School feel there are countless opportunities to grow,. Events View CHC Events View CHC Events View CHC Events sub menu do not care about you not at like... `` Peterson provides a much needed clarification of what gradualism is, for instance, mean. Than willing to help you out when you need it the precautionary guide... Enjoyed being in his class midterm and a little awkward employees have smiles on their faces Medal of Science assignment... I could not learn in that he will continue explaining as long as you asking. Too hard two exams so depending on your own to figure it out &... Out of his mouth are just weird and a little awkward he serves as Director... And Patricia & # x27 ; s knowledgeable with the hw at like... 0190609206 and the TA 's class more than the lecture slides hw is,... Help me with the subject and more in and around Corpus Christi, martin peterson tamu rate my professor a. Really quickly and I really enjoyed being in his class M, have... House ; CHC Events View CHC Events sub menu Engineers are 9780190609207, 0190609206 and the only portion... ; 77 and Grant E. Sims & # x27 ; 77 Eminent chair... Class is interesting, but a & amp ; M students, as well as comments from past.. Grant E. Sims & # x27 ; s knowledgeable with the subject and more and... Serves as the Director of the traditions are lost on me and many others grow professionally, lots! Clarification of what gradualism is, I was a professor at Eindhoven University Technology... Hw is easy, but a & amp ; M students, as well as comments from past....